Which hydraulic winch...?

Lorin

Well-Known Member
Mar 28, 2010
1,314
329
83
Bournemouth
Is a Mile Marker worth over 50% more than a comparable Champion hydraulic winch and are there any other makes worth considering?

I've been quoted £665 (exc VAT) for a Mile Marker HF12 versus £435 (exc VAT) for a Champion C10000NH.
 

Ian Rubie

Moderator
I am in uk
Feb 24, 2010
925
88
48
Bordon Hampshire
I have no experience of Champion but can say the MileMarker hydraulic winches are very well made.

My winch is an Ox which is a rebadged MileMarker. I got it from Jon who I don't think ever serviced it in 5 or 6 years of ownership. I used it for about a year, again with zero maintenance. It has never given any problems.

I did strip and clean it when I fitted the upgraded motor. The grease was a bit nasty but all the bits looked to be in tip top condition after a scrub in the parts washer.

With its upgraded pump and motor it is a bit of a beast now. I'll give you a demo at Lincomb.

Ian
 

Jon Wildsmith

Super Moderator
Supporter
Guru
I am in england
Feb 24, 2010
6,727
148
63
Stourbridge, West Midlands, England
Garage
Ian Rubie said:
I have no experience of Champion but can say the MileMarker hydraulic winches are very well made. [snip] I got it from Jon who I don't think ever serviced it in 5 or 6 years of ownership.
I bought it second hand (about 12 months old) in March 2002, it pulled more trees out the ground than it did trucks but it got dunked in plenty of muck :D So that's about 9 years of no maintenance and it just needed a bit of grease? :thumbup:

That sounds like a good price Lorin, where's that from?
 
Don't like the adverts? Remove them by becoming a supporting member.   Click here

Lorin

Well-Known Member
Mar 28, 2010
1,314
329
83
Bournemouth
I spoke to them today and explained it was for an 80...? Had a bit of a chat as I'm not intending to power it off the power steering pump. I obviously got lost in the details and failed to clarify exactly what was/was not included for the price :oops: I'll give them another call tomorrow.
 

Julian Voelcker

Well-Known Member
Mar 5, 2010
313
4
38
Herefordshire, UK
We have fitted a few Milemarkers and have been pretty happy with them.

If you are going for the Milemarker, arrange to put together your own pipework - the pipes that come in some kits are odd lengths that may not fit in with where you mount the valve block so usually best to site the valve block and then measure up for the pipes and get them made up locally.

Also be careful with mounting the valve block, it can be noisey if bolted directly to the body.

When buying the winch, do specify how it is going to be powered. Allan Byrne used to supply the MM H12 with a different motor if being run from a LC power steering pump to provide more acceptable speeds - I have a US sourced one running off the power steering pump and in low range it will pull houses down, but will be overtaken by a slug trying to escape. It is more acceptable in high gear, but then pretty gutless - with a more appropriate motor on the winch it tends to run better.

Having said that during the next couple of weeks we will be designing the mounts to run a ZF74 pump off the crank on 12 and 24 valve engines - we have a rough design already, but just need to fabricate it up.
 

Gav Peter

Well-Known Member
I am in england
Mar 1, 2010
4,843
9
38
The Wirral, NW Ingerland
Nah, you could knock that out over breakfast Jon... :p

I must admit to being vay impressed with Ian's winch - I couldn't stop laughing as I was dragged up the field at Lincomb at such a rate of knots!!!
 

Allchin

Active Member
Nov 16, 2010
67
12
18
Julian Voelcker said:
We have fitted a few Milemarkers and have been pretty happy with them.

If you are going for the Milemarker, arrange to put together your own pipework - the pipes that come in some kits are odd lengths that may not fit in with where you mount the valve block so usually best to site the valve block and then measure up for the pipes and get them made up locally.

Also be careful with mounting the valve block, it can be noisey if bolted directly to the body.

When buying the winch, do specify how it is going to be powered. Allan Byrne used to supply the MM H12 with a different motor if being run from a LC power steering pump to provide more acceptable speeds - I have a US sourced one running off the power steering pump and in low range it will pull houses down, but will be overtaken by a slug trying to escape. It is more acceptable in high gear, but then pretty gutless - with a more appropriate motor on the winch it tends to run better.

Having said that during the next couple of weeks we will be designing the mounts to run a ZF74 pump off the crank on 12 and 24 valve engines - we have a rough design already, but just need to fabricate it up.

Have you completed the project ready for sale?

Stephen
 
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock    No Thanks